Charger Challenge
2026 — Draper, UT/US
Character Spar
Event Description:
Character SPAR Debate is a fast-paced, imaginative debate event where students argue real-world topics through the lens of a fictional or historical character. Competitors must think on their feet, adapt their arguments to match their character’s voice and values, and engage in direct, persuasive clash with their opponent.
Think: debate meets improv.
Purpose
The goal of Character SPAR is to develop quick thinking, creativity, and persuasive speaking. Success comes not just from making strong arguments, but from embodying a character while debating clearly and effectively.
How It Works
Teams & Roles
- 1 student per side: Affirmative vs. Negative
- Each student debates as a chosen or assigned character (e.g., Sherlock Holmes, Hermione Granger, Abraham Lincoln, etc.)
Topic Selection
- The judge provides two possible resolutions
- Coin toss: Winner chooses the topic or side; the other selects the remaining option
Preparation
- 3–5 minutes of prep
- Notes allowed (no internet unless explicitly permitted)
- Students should prepare 2–3 clear arguments consistent with their character’s perspective
Round Structure
(~16–20 minutes total)
- Affirmative Constructive (2 min) – Presents case in character
- Negative Constructive (2 min) – Presents opposing case in character
- Crossfire (2 min) – Direct questioning and clash
- Affirmative Rebuttal (2 min) – Refutes and extends key ideas
- Negative Rebuttal (2 min) – Refutes and extends key ideas
- Grand Crossfire (2 min) – Open, dynamic exchange
- Final Focus – Affirmative (1 min) – Closing argument
- Final Focus – Negative (1 min) – Closing argument
(Times may be shortened for faster rounds.)
Speaker Expectations
- Stay in character while remaining clear and understandable
- Prioritize persuasion over memorization or heavy evidence
- Engage in direct clash — respond, don’t ignore
- Use creativity, humor, and personality without losing argumentative focus
Judging Criteria
- Characterization: Did the speaker convincingly embody their character?
- Clarity: Were arguments easy to follow?
- Clash: Did they directly engage the opponent’s points?
- Persuasion: Were they convincing and compelling?
- Creativity: Did they use the character in a clever, meaningful way?
At its best, Character SPAR is energetic, unpredictable, and highly entertaining—where strong debaters don’t just argue well, they become someone else to do it.