ParkerHilo Scrimmage
2026 — Kamuela, HI/US
Open Lincoln-Douglas
Event Description:
Lincoln-Douglas Debate Judging Criteria
Lincoln-Douglas is a one-on-one value debate centered on competing moral and philosophical principles. Competitors must argue whether the resolution is fundamentally right or wrong, rather than simply proposing a policy plan. Please set aside your personal views on the topic and decide the round strictly on the arguments presented.
As you evaluate the debaters, base your decision on the following core elements:
-
Value & Criterion Framework: Each debater should establish a core value (such as justice, morality, or liberty) and a criterion (the standard used to measure or achieve that value). Evaluate who establishes the more compelling framework and proves their side better upholds it.
-
Clash & Refutation: The winning debater must directly answer their opponent’s arguments while defending their own case. Look for thorough line-by-line refutation rather than two separate speeches talking past each other.
-
Logic, Evidence & Warranting: Claims require clear logical reasoning (warrants) and credible philosophical or empirical support. Reward debaters who clearly explain why their reasoning holds up and why their opponent’s falls short.
-
Crystallization & Weighing: In the final rebuttals, debaters should narrow the round down to the key voting issues. Evaluate how clearly they weigh competing impacts and explain why their framework or arguments ultimately win the ballot.
-
Cross-Examination & Delivery: During cross-examination, look for strategic questioning and composed, direct responses. Throughout the round, speakers should communicate clearly, persuasively, and at an understandable pace.