ParkerHilo Scrimmage
2026 — Kamuela, HI/US
Novice Public Forum
Event Description:
Public Forum Debate Judging Criteria
Public Forum is a two-on-two debate focusing on a timely, controversial topic. Arguments should be accessible to a well-informed citizen—no specialized jargon or ultra-fast "spreading" is permitted. Please set aside your personal opinions on the resolution and decide the round strictly on the arguments presented.
As you evaluate the teams, base your decision on the following core elements:
-
Clash & Refutation: The winning team must directly engage with their opponents' case. Evaluate how effectively each pair responds to attacks on their own arguments while refuting the other side’s core points.
-
Evidence & Warranting: Assertions are not enough. Look for teams that back up their claims with logical reasoning (warrants) and credible, relevant evidence, and clearly explain why their evidence outweighs their opponents'.
-
Weighing & Impact: By the end of the round (especially in the Summary and Final Focus speeches), teams should crystallize the debate. Reward the team that gives you clear reasons why their impacts—such as scope, magnitude, or probability—matter more than the other side's.
-
Crossfire Engagement: Both partners must participate in the Grand Crossfire, and individuals should be poised during earlier Crossfires. Look for pointed, strategic questioning and confident, direct answers without interrupting or dominating the floor.
-
Persuasive Delivery: Arguments should be clear, conversational, and well-structured. Evaluate speakers on vocal clarity, pacing, organization, and overall professionalism.