ParkerHilo Scrimmage

2026 — Kamuela, HI/US

Extemp

Abbreviation EXT
Format Speech
Entry Fee $0.00 (Plus $0.00 / individual)
Entry 1 competitors per entry

Event Description:

Extemporaneous Speaking Judging Criteria

Extemporaneous Speaking is a 7-minute limited-preparation event in which competitors draw a current-events question (domestic or international) and have 30 minutes to prepare an original, well-researched speech using pre-collected offline files or permitted research materials. Speakers should deliver the speech without notes while directly answering the drawn question.

As you rank the round, evaluate each speaker on the following core elements:

  • Direct Answer & Thesis: The speaker must state the exact question verbatim and take a clear, direct stance. Every main point should logically support that answer rather than offering a broad, unfocused overview of the topic.

  • Evidence & Source Citation: Arguments must be backed by recent, credible sources (such as major news outlets, think tanks, or academic journals). Look for specific citations—naming the publication and date—integrated smoothly into the analysis rather than listed mechanically.

  • Depth of Analysis: Facts alone are not enough. Reward speakers who explain the broader context, connect cause and effect, address counterarguments or nuances, and demonstrate genuine understanding of the issue.

  • Organization & Structure: The speech should follow a clear, logical roadmap: an engaging introduction that states the question and previews the main points, distinct body sections with smooth transitions, and a conclusion that ties back to the opening hook and thesis.

  • Delivery & Time Management: Speakers should appear poised, authoritative, and conversational without relying on notes. Evaluate vocal clarity, pacing, eye contact, and purposeful movement, as well as how effectively they use the 7-minute time limit.